Universal Coaching Centre -

Enter your keyword

8053+ OFFICERS SERVING THE NATION UNIVERSAL COACHING CENTRE Let's join hands together in bringing Your Name in Elite officers list. JOIN US 25 YEARS OF EXCELLENCE MEET NEW FRIENDS AND STUDY WITH EXPERTS JOIN US Nothing is better than having friends study together. Each student can learn from others through by teamwork building and playing interesting games. Following instruction of experts, you and friends will gain best scores.

ULP Click here! Click here! Classroom Programme NRA-CET Test Series
Click here ! Org code: XSHWV

post

GUBERNATORIAL WALKOUTS AND CONSTITUTIONAL LIMITS

Why in the News?

  • Assembly Walkouts: Governors in Karnataka, Tamil Nadu and Kerala walked out or selectively read special addresses during inaugural Assembly sessions.
  • Judicial Debate: Karnataka government is considering approaching the Supreme Court for clarity on the constitutionality of such walkouts.
  • Opposition Concern: State leaders argue Governors lack discretion to skip or abort Cabinet-approved addresses to legislatures.

 

CONSTITUTIONAL POSITION ON GOVERNOR’S ADDRESS

  • Mandatory Duty: Article 176(1) uses the word “shall”, making it compulsory for Governors to address the Legislature at the session’s commencement.
  • Cabinet Advice: The special address reflects State Cabinet policy, and Governors are constitutionally bound to act on aid and advice.
  • No Selective Reading: Skipping paragraphs undermines the collective responsibility of the elected government to the Assembly.
  • People’s Mandate: The address indirectly communicates policies to the people represented in the Legislature, reinforcing democratic accountability.
  • Limited Role: Governors are not policy-makers but constitutional heads with clearly demarcated functions.

SUPREME COURT’S INTERPRETATION

  • Tamil Nadu Case: The Court held gubernatorial discretion cannot negate the authority of a responsible elected government.
  • Shamsher Singh Ruling: A seven-judge Bench ruled that public stances critical of Cabinet policy are an “unconstitutional faux pas”.
  • Nabam Rebia Judgment: Discretion exists only in explicitly stated areas, such as assent to Bills or government formation.
  • Executive Function: Addressing the House under Articles 175 and 176 is an executive act requiring ministerial advice.
  • Remote Control Doctrine: Even limited gubernatorial discretion operates under Union accountability to Parliament.

GOVERNOR’S ROLE IN PARLIAMENTARY DEMOCRACY

●      Constitutional Head: Governors function as nominal heads, while real executive power vests in elected governments.

●      Defined Discretion: The Constitution specifies limited discretionary areas, preventing arbitrary gubernatorial action.

●      Federal Balance: Proper conduct preserves Centre–State harmony and federal equilibrium.

●      Judicial Oversight: Courts act as guardians of constitutional boundaries when gubernatorial actions are questioned.

●      Democratic Principle: Upholding legislative supremacy ensures parliamentary democracy remains robust and accountable.